# How to Audit Fulfillment.com Value-Added Services (VAS), Kitting & Hourly Labor: Discrepancies & Dispute Guide

> Audit itemized VAS hours, SKU bundling fees, compliance labeling, and ad-hoc warehouse labor on Fulfillment.com invoices.

## 1. Invoice Labels & Triggers

- **Common Invoice Labels**: Special Projects, VAS Labor, Kitting Fee, Assembly Surcharge, Hourly Labor, Ad Hoc Warehouse Services
- **Trigger Condition**: Special warehouse tasks outside standard pick/pack flows: assembling multi-item product bundles, applying retail compliance barcodes, or conducting manual inventory cycles.

## 2. Contract Verification & Audit Formula

- **Contract Focus**: Prior written approval clauses (work order authorization requirements) and defined hourly rates ($40-$65/hr) in 15-minute billing increments.
- **Audit Formula**: `Billed VAS Hours without confirmed Merchant Work Order Ticket = $0. Unauthorized project hours are disputed 100%.`
- **Dispute Argument**: Special project labor was invoiced without prerequisite merchant authorization, or recurring round-number hours were billed without task completion logs.

## 3. Evidence Checklist

1. Approved merchant work order or email ticket authorizing specific project scope
2. Warehouse floor supervisor timecard or punch-in/out activity ledger
3. Contract schedule defining approved labor categories and hourly rates

## 4. Frequently Asked Questions

### Why are special project fees the vaguest line items on {provider} invoices?

Unlike pick/pack fees tied to discrete order IDs, 'Special Projects' or 'VAS' lines are often entered as arbitrary lump-sum hours (e.g. '10.0 hours @ $55/hr') by warehouse managers balancing their monthly labor budgets.

### What is required before {provider} can bill me for hourly labor?

Nearly all standard 3PL agreements require prior written authorization (via ticket, email, or formal work order) before billable hourly labor can commence.

### Can I dispute kitting fees if I was also charged pick fees for each item?

Yes! If your contract establishes a flat $1.50 kitting fee to bundle SKU A and SKU B, and the invoice charges $1.50 assembly PLUS a $0.40 pick fee for SKU A and $0.40 for SKU B, that is blatant duplicate billing.

## 5. Formal Dispute Letter Template

```text
To: Fulfillment.com Billing & Account Resolution Team
Subject: Formal Dispute: VAS & Kitting Labor Discrepancies – Invoice #[INVOICE_NUMBER] – [MERCHANT_NAME]
Date: [TODAY_DATE]

Dear Fulfillment.com Billing Department,

Upon line-by-line reconciliation of our latest invoice #[INVOICE_NUMBER] against our executed rate schedule and confirmed operational terms, we have identified unauthorized billing items under Value-Added Services (VAS), Kitting & Hourly Labor.

Specific Discrepancy Findings:
- Charge Family / Surcharge: Value-Added Services (VAS), Kitting & Hourly Labor
- Invoiced Label: Special Projects / VAS Labor / Kitting Fee / Assembly Surcharge / Hourly Labor / Ad Hoc Warehouse Services
- Contract Defense: Special project labor was invoiced without prerequisite merchant authorization, or recurring round-number hours were billed without task completion logs.
- Rule Verification: Billed VAS Hours without confirmed Merchant Work Order Ticket = $0. Unauthorized project hours are disputed 100%.
- Contractual Notice Window: Per our agreement terms (Fulfillment.com publishes no dispute procedure: its published terms cover only its website, so the dispute window, the notice address and the payment terms are those in your contract.), this notice is formally filed within the required window.

Please review the attached line item ledger (Exhibit A), apply a credit memo of $[TOTAL_DISPUTED_AMOUNT] to our account, or provide the underlying carrier measurement/warehouse supervisor logs within 10 business days.

Sincerely,
[AUTHORIZED_SIGNATURE]
[COMPANY_NAME]
[ACCOUNT_ID]
```
