Guides / Part XXVI · Audit services and software
billsharp alternative: minutes, not 17 days
Compare billsharp (human-run audits, no published price, 2x ROI guarantee) with Feeproof ($59-$299/mo self-serve, flat pricing, first audit free).
If you are looking for an alternative to billsharp to audit your 3PL invoices, the decision is not really about features. It is about who does the work. billsharp is a service: a team of people audits your invoices for you, behind a discovery call, at a price agreed in private. Feeproof is software you run yourself: you upload the invoice and the contract, and a deterministic engine returns the report and the dispute letter in minutes, at a price published on the site.
billsharp, operated by FLGS Holding GmbH and established in 2024, sells a one-time 3PL Billing Audit and an ongoing Cost Control Retainer. Feeproof is an automated, zero-integration audit engine built for ecommerce brands to check every dollar on a 3PL invoice against their contract. Here is a fact-based comparison based on what each company publishes on its website.
Comparison at a glance
| Metric | Feeproof | billsharp |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Self-serve SaaS you run yourself | A human-run audit service |
| Pricing model | Flat monthly SaaS by order volume | Fee agreed per engagement; no published price |
| Published pricing | Free audit of latest invoice ($0); then Starter $59/mo, Pro $149/mo, Business $299/mo | Does not publish pricing - fees are set in a separate agreement or statement of work |
| Percentage of recovery taken? | 0% (You keep 100% of credits) | Does not publish a percentage; its anchor is a 2x ROI guarantee |
| Setup & onboarding | Instant (Self-serve in 2 minutes) | Book a discovery call; NDA first, then forward invoices by email |
| System access required | Zero logins, zero API keys (Upload CSV or PDF) | None published - the engagement runs over email |
| Turnaround | Report and dispute letter in minutes | Most engagements complete in 17 days, covering 3-6 months of invoices |
| Deepest 3PL coverage | Any 3PL, from its invoice files | ShipBob - "We currently run this in production on ShipBob; the same method applies to any 3PL" |
| Primary deliverable | Line-by-line audit report, status for every dollar, ready-to-send dispute letter | Claim packs: a draft PDF with line evidence, sent by a person |
| Best suited for | Brands that want a monthly check they control, at a known price | Brands that want a one-off project run for them, especially on ShipBob |
Pricing: published flat rates vs. a price you get on a call
billsharp publishes no price anywhere on its site. Its terms say fees are "as agreed in the relevant engagement", in a separate agreement, order form or statement of work. The only economic anchor it publishes is its 2x ROI guarantee: if it does not identify savings worth at least double its fee, you do not pay. That is a real promise, but it cannot be compared from a web page - you learn what an audit costs by booking a discovery call and signing an agreement.
Feeproof charges transparent, published flat rates:
- Free Plan: Free audit of your latest invoice from any 3PL, with full contract extraction and dispute letter.
- Starter ($59/mo): Up to 3,000 orders/month from one 3PL, auditing invoices back 3 months.
- Pro ($149/mo): Up to 15,000 orders/month from up to three 3PLs, auditing invoices back 12 months, plus payment approval, cost per order and SKU, and a read-only link for the 3PL.
- Business ($299/mo): Up to 50,000 orders/month from any number of 3PLs, auditing invoices back 24 months, plus payment approval, cost per order and SKU, a read-only link for the 3PL, and a reply assistant that reads the 3PL's answer against the contract and drafts the reply.
There are no setup fees, no percentage of recovery, no annual contracts (month-to-month billing), and a 14-day full refund guarantee. Whether a private quote would beat these numbers for your volume is something only the call can tell you - which is itself the difference between the two models.
Onboarding and how the work gets done
- billsharp is an engagement. You book a discovery call, sign an NDA, and forward your invoices by email. Its method page describes a productised back end - pricing lines read from your contract, claim "packs" assembled as a draft PDF with line evidence - with a human sending the claims. A one-time audit covers 3 to 6 months of invoices, and most engagements complete in 17 days. It also offers a free invoice check, with a reply within one business day.
- Feeproof is a file drop and a few minutes. You never share your Shopify admin password, your 3PL portal login, or your carrier API keys. You upload the invoice files (CSV or PDF, including scanned documents) and your signed contract or rate card. Feeproof's deterministic engine runs 15 code checks (MATH, R1 to R5, R7 to R14 and SUM), gives every billed dollar one of five explicit statuses (Supported, Calculation mismatch, Conflicts with terms, Needs evidence, Not tested), and drafts the dispute letter automatically - included in every plan, not negotiated as part of an engagement.
Scope: a ShipBob-deep service vs. an any-3PL monthly check
- Choose billsharp if: You fulfil with ShipBob and want its deepest bench - it has a dedicated ShipBob audit page and a published checklist of where ShipBob invoices go wrong, and ShipBob is the platform it runs in production. Choose it, too, if you would rather hand a defined backlog (3 to 6 months of invoices) to a team and receive claim packs than run software yourself, and you are comfortable pricing that through a sales process.
- Choose Feeproof if: Your problem is recurring, not one-off: a new invoice arrives every month, from any 3PL, and you want each one checked against your contract as it lands - at a published flat price, with the dispute letter included, and with nothing to book, sign or forward by email.
Try the free audit first
Before booking a discovery call, you can audit your most recent invoice with Feeproof at no cost and see exactly which dollars are supported, which are calculation mismatches, and which conflict with your contract terms. billsharp will also check an invoice free and reply within one business day. Run the same invoice through both, compare the findings, and then decide whether you want a team on an engagement - or a check that simply runs every month.
billsharp's engagement terms, 2x ROI guarantee and 17-day figure are as published on billsharp.co, read on November 18, 2026; check its site before you rely on them.
What each 3PL audit service costs at your volume
Adjust your monthly shipped orders and estimated invoice errors recovered. Feeproof tier prices below read directly from our current pricing plans.
Active 3PL warehouses
| Service | Pricing model | Est. monthly cost | Annual cost | Net kept (Credits - Fee) | Turnaround & access |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| FeeproofRecommended | Pro · Flat monthly (regular $199 from 2027-02-01) | $149 | $1,788 | $1,351 | Minutes · Files only (CSV/PDF) |
| WareAudit | Flat monthly · Dispute reply add-on extra | $299 | $3,588 | $1,201 | Minutes · ShipBob/Hero token or CSV |
| ThreeTracks | Flat monthly (human-verified up to 12k orders) | $300 | $3,600 | $1,200 | Within 5 working days · Email files |
| SpendVerify | $99 base + 20% of credits ($499 cap) | $399 | $4,788 | $1,101 | Files sent by email · Founding terms |
| Implentio | Platform fee from $1,000 / mo | ≥ $1,000 | ≥ $12,000 | ≤ $500 | Weeks · Data & BI integrations |
| Parcel contingency (35%) | 35% share of recovered parcel refunds | $525 | $6,300 | $975 | Carrier claims only · Excludes 3PL fees |
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between billsharp and Feeproof?
billsharp is a service: a team of people audits your invoices behind a discovery call, at a price agreed in private. Feeproof is software you run yourself: you upload the invoice and the contract, and a deterministic engine returns the report and the dispute letter in minutes, at a published price.
How does billsharp charge?
It publishes no price: fees are “as agreed in the relevant engagement”. Its only economic anchor is a 2x ROI guarantee: if it does not identify savings worth at least double its fee, you do not pay. Feeproof publishes Starter $59, Pro $149 and Business $299 a month, with a free first audit.
How long does a billsharp audit take?
Most engagements complete in 17 days and cover 3 to 6 months of invoices; its free invoice check gets a reply within one business day. Feeproof’s report and dispute letter arrive in minutes.
When is billsharp the better fit?
If you fulfil with ShipBob and want its deepest bench (it runs in production on ShipBob and publishes a checklist of where ShipBob invoices go wrong), or you would rather hand a defined backlog of 3 to 6 months to a team and receive claim packs. Feeproof fits a recurring problem: a new invoice every month, from any 3PL, checked as it lands.