# Feeproof vs ChatGPT and spreadsheets for auditing 3PL invoices

If you already have a 3PL contract PDF and a 4,000-row CSV invoice, it is tempting to paste both into ChatGPT or Claude, ask what is wrong, and save yourself a subscription. On a five-line test, it looks convincing. On a real monthly warehouse bill, the wheels come off in predictable ways.

This guide separates what general AI chats and spreadsheets are good at from where deterministic 3PL audit software takes over, and shows why Feeproof refuses to let a language model invent a single number.

## Comparison at a glance

| Dimension | ChatGPT / Claude + Excel | Feeproof |
| --- | --- | --- |
| **Role of AI** | AI reads, writes formulas, guesses and sums numbers | AI reads layouts and extracts contract quotes only; **code computes every dollar** |
| **Row & page coverage** | Context limits and tool timeouts silently drop rows on long CSVs or scanned PDFs | Five-status conservation check forces every billed cent to sum to the invoice total |
| **Contract citation** | May paraphrase or invent a rate from memory | Attaches the verbatim sentence from your contract to every rate before checking runs |
| **Cross-record checks** | Requires manual VLOOKUPs against Shopify exports and prior invoices | Built-in `SUM`, `R14` (unshipped orders), `R2` (recurring creep), `R5` (missing credits) |
| **Audit memory** | New prompt every month; promised credits are forgotten | Versioned contract pricing, promised credit register across months, dispute letter included |
| **Price** | Seat cost + 2–5 hours of operator time every month | Latest invoice free ($0); then flat $59 / $149 / $299 a month |

## Three failure modes when auditing 3PL bills in a general AI chat

### 1. Silent dropped rows on real invoice sizes

A mid-market DTC invoice with daily pick-and-pack, per-SKU storage snapshots, URO penalties, and freight adjustments easily runs 1,500 to 15,000 rows, or 30+ pages of PDF tables. General chat sandboxes hit row caps, memory ceilings, or OCR line wraps — and still hand back a confident paragraph saying "Total overcharges found: $1,420" without proving it read lines 1,800 through 4,200.

Feeproof enforces a hard mathematical invariant on every run: **every billed dollar gets one of five statuses** (*Supported*, *Calculation mismatch*, *Conflicts with terms*, *Needs evidence*, *Not tested*), and the sum of those five buckets must equal the invoice total down to the cent. Nothing is silently skipped.

### 2. Tiered pick-and-pack and DIM rounding errors

3PL billing math has sharp edge cases: base pick including the first unit vs per-unit extra picks (`5,000 × $2.30 + 4,000 × $0.60`), minimum monthly spend counted as the shortfall vs a floor (`R10`), free monthly allowances deducted before billing (`R7`), and dimensional weight divisors (`(L × W × H) / divisor`, rounded up to the next whole pound).

A language model predicts tokens; it is not an accounting calculator. Asking a chat model to multiply decimal rates across mixed units produces off-by-one errors you then have to audit yourself — defeating the point of automating the check.

### 3. No durable credit register or repeatable proof

Finding an overcharge in Excel is only half the job. When a 3PL agrees on an email thread to issue a `$640` credit memo next month, a spreadsheet prompt forgets it by next cycle unless your team maintains a manual ledger. In Feeproof, promised credits stay in the **credit register (`R5`)** across subsequent invoices until the full credit actually appears on a bill.

## When spreadsheets and AI chats still make sense

- **One-off exploratory modeling**: if you are building a custom network model or sensitivity table for a new warehouse RFP, Excel or a quick [DIM weight](/tools/dim-weight) / [cost per order calculator](/tools/cost-per-order) check is ideal.
- **Smaller CSV spot checks**: our free [Invoice quick check](/tools/quick-check) already spots duplicate charges, new fees, and line-item arithmetic errors directly from a single CSV or PDF without an account.

## How Feeproof splits reading from math

Feeproof uses the best of both worlds without the hallucination risk:

1. **The reader extracts**: an AI reader learns unknown CSV/PDF layouts, OCRs scanned pages locally, and parses your quote or contract into structured rate rows — each pinned to the exact source quote.
2. **You confirm the contract facts**: you verify the extracted rates once so only confirmed pricing rules participate in checks.
3. **Deterministic code runs the 15 checks**: decimal-exact TypeScript code computes every line (`MATH`, `R1`–`R5`, `R7`–`R14`, `SUM`), proves the five-status sum matches the invoice total, and drafts the dispute letter quoting both the clause and the exact invoice lines.

Upload your latest invoice and contract to run the [15 checks](/guides/what-is-a-3pl-invoice-audit) free before paying anything. [Start your free audit](/login) or use the [Quote to rate card](/tools/rate-card) tool first.
