# Monthly minimum: what a top-up should actually be

A monthly minimum is a floor on what you pay your 3PL in a month, whatever your volume. If your billable activity reaches the floor, the minimum costs you nothing. If it falls short, you pay a top-up equal to the shortfall - the difference between the minimum and what you were billed, not the minimum again.

## The definition that decides everything

A minimum is defined on a base: the set of charges that count toward it. Most contracts define the base as fulfilment fees - pick, pack, storage, receiving. Some include postage and pass-through carrier charges, which makes the minimum far easier to reach and the top-up far smaller. Two contracts with the same $2,500 minimum and different bases are different deals. The second definition that matters is the period: calendar month is standard, but some minimums run on the 3PL's billing cycle, and a brand shipping seasonally can fall short in a four-week cycle it would have cleared in a calendar month.

**Example.** Your minimum is $2,500 on fulfilment fees. In a slow month you are billed $1,940 in fulfilment fees and $6,300 in postage. If postage counted toward the base, there would be no top-up at all. On a fulfilment-fees base, the correct top-up is $2,500 − $1,940 = $560. An invoice that adds a "minimum charge" of $2,500 on top of the $1,940 has not applied a minimum - it has charged the floor as a fee, overbilling $1,940.

## How minimums get misapplied

Four patterns recur. The top-up is charged in a month when activity already cleared the minimum - the check is simply never run. The top-up equals the full minimum instead of the shortfall, as in the example. The base quietly widens or narrows: pass-through postage counted toward the minimum in the 3PL's favour when computing whether you cleared it, then excluded when computing the top-up. And the minimum itself is taken from the wrong tier or an old contract version after a renegotiation lowered it. Each pattern is small enough to survive a glance at the total and regular enough to bill every slow month of the year.

## How to check it

Recompute, don't review. From the contract, take the minimum amount and its base definition. From the invoice, sum only the charges inside that base. The top-up on the invoice should equal the minimum minus that sum, and should be zero whenever the sum clears the minimum. Feeproof runs exactly this as check R10 on every invoice, and the top-up line has its own entry in the [glossary](/guides/glossary). How minimums interact with peak windows and dispute deadlines is covered in [minimums, peak windows and dispute windows](/guides/minimums-peak-and-dispute-windows).
