← All case studies
Invoice IntegrityHealth & sports nutrition · Single 3PL warehouse · Supplemental invoice issued for late carrier charges

Duplicate charges sitting right in the open across re-issued bills.

When the 3PL issued a new invoice to capture $2.8K in late carrier adjustments, it re-billed the entire $38.4K base fulfillment period under a fresh invoice number.

Key figures from the audit

  • $38.4K

    Original invoice total that matched its own backup file

  • $2.8K

    Late carrier adjustments the 3PL intended to add

  • $41.2K

    Re-issued invoice under a new number ($38.4K + $2.8K)

  • 2×

    The entire $38.4K base period billed and collected twice

Why this billing error happens

Each individual invoice PDF agreed with its own attached CSV backup, so checking one invoice in isolation showed zero math errors. Only by reconciling Order IDs and charge timestamps across historical invoices did it become clear that 100% of the prior period's $38.4K charges were included a second time inside the new $41.2K bill.

How Feeproof catches it

Rule R1 (Duplicate Billing Across Invoices) hashes Order IDs, tracking numbers, and dated fee lines against your prior invoices for the same 3PL so re-billed periods are caught immediately.

How the discrepancy compounded

  1. 1Original $38.4K fulfillment invoice audited and paid on schedule
  2. 23PL discovers $2.8K in unbilled carrier fees and issues a new $41.2K invoice for the full period
  3. 3Cross-invoice Order ID deduplication flags the $38.4K overlap before payment clears

Want your own invoices checked?

Run cross-invoice duplicate detection across your recent 3PL bills.

Start free audit