← All case studies
Rate Card GovernanceMulti-brand DTC consumer goods · Smaller of two brands · 3PL-managed rate card · 5 months running

The rate card on the invoice didn't match the contract they signed.

For five consecutive billing cycles, the unit rates billed on the invoice differed from the signed rate exhibit because nobody cross-checked the secondary brand's account setup.

Key figures from the audit

  • $68.5K

    Overcharged by billing off the outdated rate card

  • 0

    Invoices that failed a standard AP totals check

  • 1 of 2

    Storefronts left on the legacy rate schedule

  • 5 months

    The discrepancy ran before an automated check caught it

Why this billing error happens

One team negotiates the contract amendment; another approves the monthly payable. When a multi-brand operator renegotiates fulfillment tiers, the 3PL often updates the flagship storefront in the WMS billing table while leaving the smaller brand on legacy list rates. Because invoice totals still look mathematically consistent, standard AP reviews pass them straight through.

How Feeproof catches it

Rule R4 (Rate Above Contract) compares every billed line's effective unit rate (Amount ÷ Quantity) against your confirmed contract exhibit and flags any line billed on an outdated or unapplied rate schedule.

How the discrepancy compounded

  1. 1New negotiated rate schedule signed across two sister DTC brands
  2. 23PL updates billing tables for the primary brand, leaving the second brand on prior rates
  3. 3Five monthly invoices are approved and paid before line-level rate verification spots the $68.5K gap

Want your own invoices checked?

Verify that every rate on your latest invoice matches the contract you actually signed.

Start free audit