← All case studies
Weight/DIM ValidationOutdoor consumer goods · 12,840 packages · Regional & parcel carriers · Misapplied handling surcharges

A per-parcel surcharge small enough to slip by, because nobody checked the full export.

A $4.40 handling surcharge was triggered on thousands of standard parcels that fell well below the carrier's dimension threshold — impossible to catch by spot-checking a dozen rows.

Key figures from the audit

  • $19,420

    Cumulative overcharges from misapplied handling fees

  • $4.40

    Average surcharge error per affected parcel

  • 4,414

    Shipments billed for handling they did not trigger

  • 100%

    Of parcel rows must be audited — sampling misses it

Why this billing error happens

Spot-checking ten or twenty tracking numbers a month cannot catch a four-dollar surcharge repeated across thousands of shipments. When a carton dimension in the WMS is off by half an inch, or a carrier surcharge rule is applied to the wrong box family, the per-order variance looks like normal zone noise while quietly draining five figures.

How Feeproof catches it

Feeproof recomputes billable weight and surcharge eligibility across 100% of your shipment detail export against your contracted DIM divisor and size thresholds.

How the discrepancy compounded

  1. 1Non-standard handling surcharge erroneously triggered on standard cartons
  2. 2$4.40 surcharge repeated across 4,414 shipments out of 12,840 total packages
  3. 3Full-population parcel audit flags $19,420 in recoverable surcharge credits

Want your own invoices checked?

Check every shipment row in your backup file against your contracted carrier rules.

Start free audit