3PL vs 3PL Billing Comparison

ShipBob vs Red Stag Fulfillment billing & guarantees compared

Compare ShipBob's published multi-fee Help Center schedule with Red Stag Fulfillment's custom heavy/oversize fulfillment quotes and zero-shrinkage guarantee.

Pair overview

ShipBob suits standard DTC cartons with published add-on tables, whereas Red Stag focuses on heavy/bulky SKUs with private quotes backed by explicit guarantees (zero shrinkage, fast receiving, and UPS/FedEx 2026 size thresholds).

Every figure below comes strictly from each 3PL's public pricing pages, help center, and Terms as reviewed in November 2026. Unpublished items stay marked as contract-only.

Side-by-side billing & dispute terms

Comparison of publicly disclosed pricing rules, billing cadences, minimums, peak surcharges, and dispute windows.
Billing dimensionShipBobRed Stag Fulfillment
Price disclosureAdd-on and exception rates published in Help Center; per-package fulfillment rate is quote-based.No public rate card; publishes four operational guarantees and UPS/FedEx oversize thresholds.
Billing cadenceSplits billing into 6 separate invoice types; storage billed twice monthly (15th & month-end); payment daily, weekly, or monthly.Monthly/contracted cadence set in customer agreement.
Monthly minimumMinimum monthly spend and order volume exist in quote/plan; exact dollar figure is not published.Custom-quoted in customer agreement; not published on site.
Storage & snapshotsPro-rated daily: Bin $5, small shelf $7.50 (Yorkville, IL), shelf $10, pallet $40 / month.Custom-quoted; 0% shrinkage allowance (lost/damaged stock reimbursed at merchant cost).
Inbound & receivingPer WRO: $40 flat for first 2 hours, then $45/hr; URO $25/day (no WRO), $10/day (quantity/barcode), $5/day (RTS); $150/$600 no-show.Receiving SLA published as fast as 1 hour; custom receiving rates sit in quote.
Peak & rate changesPublished Help Center rates; 3% credit card processing fee added on USD US fulfillment centers when paying by card.Follows 2026 UPS/FedEx size thresholds: Additional Handling (>48" longest, >50 lb) and Large Package/Oversize (>96" longest, >110 lb).
Dispute & claim clock90 days from transaction date for operational error corrections; 48 hours from delivery for inventory discrepancies.No billing dispute window published on website; governed entirely by your customer agreement.
What to audit firstReconcile all 6 invoice downloads against your order export and check URO daily penalties after the WRO grace window.Reconcile shrinkage reimbursements at unit cost, verify heavyweight Additional Handling/Oversize triggers against SKU dimensions, and track SLA credits.

What changes when you audit either invoice

  • Red Stag publishes zero shrinkage tolerance (damaged or lost stock reimbursed at your cost) alongside fast receiving promises as quick as 1 hour.
  • Red Stag maps oversize billing directly to published 2026 UPS/FedEx thresholds (Additional Handling >48" or >50 lb; Oversize >96" or >110 lb), which must match SKU master dimensions.
  • ShipBob charges published WRO hourly receiving ($40 first 2h + $45/hr) and $150/$600 no-show fines.

Open individual 3PL audit guides & fee playbooks

ShipBob invoice audit

Nine checks from ShipBob's published rules: six invoice types, per-WRO receiving, URO daily fees, storage pro-rated daily and a 90-day correction window.

Red Stag Fulfillment invoice audit

Red Stag publishes no rate card, but four guarantees: zero shrinkage, on-time shipping, accurate orders, fast receiving. Seven checks that follow.

Frequently asked questions

Which is better for auditing heavyweight or oversized SKUs?

Either requires checking exact SKU dimensions against carrier/warehouse brackets—on Red Stag specifically verify the 48"/50 lb Additional Handling and 96"/110 lb Oversize thresholds against your signed quote.

How does Red Stag's zero-shrinkage promise appear on invoices?

Lost or damaged goods under Red Stag's custody are reimbursed at your unit cost rather than discounted by a 0.5%-2% shrinkage allowance.

Are Red Stag rates public?

No. Unlike ShipBob's Help Center add-on tables, Red Stag rates for receiving, storage, and fulfillment are completely custom-quoted.