3PL vs 3PL Billing Comparison

ShipBob vs ShipHero Fulfillment billing & audit rules compared

Compare ShipBob's unbundled 6-invoice model with ShipHero Fulfillment's bundled flat per-order pricing across the lower 48 states.

Pair overview

ShipBob separates package fulfillment, storage, receiving, returns, and add-ons into 6 downloadable invoice types; ShipHero sells one flat per-order fulfillment bundle (pick, pack, box, postage) with zero lower-48 zone pricing.

Every figure below comes strictly from each 3PL's public pricing pages, help center, and Terms as reviewed in November 2026. Unpublished items stay marked as contract-only.

Side-by-side billing & dispute terms

Comparison of publicly disclosed pricing rules, billing cadences, minimums, peak surcharges, and dispute windows.
Billing dimensionShipBobShipHero
Price disclosureAdd-on and exception rates published in Help Center; per-package fulfillment rate is quote-based.Bundle structure published (one flat per-order rate incl. pick, pack, box, postage; $0 setup); exact rates & storage sit in quote.
Billing cadenceSplits billing into 6 separate invoice types; storage billed twice monthly (15th & month-end); payment daily, weekly, or monthly.Contract-defined cadence against flat per-order fulfillment charges and separate storage/VAS lines.
Monthly minimumMinimum monthly spend and order volume exist in quote/plan; exact dollar figure is not published.Not published externally — governed solely by your signed quote.
Storage & snapshotsPro-rated daily: Bin $5, small shelf $7.50 (Yorkville, IL), shelf $10, pallet $40 / month.Not published on rate card; founder interviews describe ~60 days free storage then ~$5/bin or ~$30/pallet.
Inbound & receivingPer WRO: $40 flat for first 2 hours, then $45/hr; URO $25/day (no WRO), $10/day (quantity/barcode), $5/day (RTS); $150/$600 no-show.Not published on rate card — quote must specify receiving, box, and returns billing units.
Peak & rate changesPublished Help Center rates; 3% credit card processing fee added on USD US fulfillment centers when paying by card.Lower-48 flat per-order rate explicitly excludes destination zone pricing; watch out for zone or materials unbundling.
Dispute & claim clock90 days from transaction date for operational error corrections; 48 hours from delivery for inventory discrepancies.No published dispute window or billing-dispute workflow for fulfillment clients.
What to audit firstReconcile all 6 invoice downloads against your order export and check URO daily penalties after the WRO grace window.Verify nothing included in the bundle (pick, standard pack, box, postage) is billed as a second separate line, and confirm no lower-48 zone pricing appears.

What changes when you audit either invoice

  • On ShipBob, add-on fees ($0.35 extra pick, $0.45 fragile, WRO receiving) are audited against public Help Center tables; on ShipHero, any unbundled line for pick, standard box, or lower-48 zone surcharge contradicts its bundle promise.
  • ShipBob explicitly adds 3% on USD US card payments; ShipHero states a $0 setup fee on its fulfillment service (separate from its WMS software).
  • ShipHero publishes no dispute deadline at all, making rate-drift comparison from invoice #1 to latest essential.

Open individual 3PL audit guides & fee playbooks

ShipBob invoice audit

Nine checks from ShipBob's published rules: six invoice types, per-WRO receiving, URO daily fees, storage pro-rated daily and a 90-day correction window.

ShipHero invoice audit

ShipHero publishes a bundle, not a rate card: one flat per-order rate with pick, pack, box and postage inside, no zone pricing. Ten checks at its edges.

Frequently asked questions

Why are ShipHero invoice audits mostly classification checks?

Because ShipHero bundles pick, pack, box, and postage into one flat per-order quote with no lower-48 zone pricing, any separate box, pick, or zone charge on an eligible order is double-billing.

How does ShipBob handle extra picks compared to ShipHero?

ShipBob publicly prices extra picks beyond your plan allowance at $0.35/unit. ShipHero keeps unit fees in your quote (founder interviews cite ~25 cents after 2 included picks/inserts).

What about onboarding and setup fees?

ShipHero publishes $0 setup for fulfillment (never confuse with WMS onboarding fees). ShipBob sets implementation fees privately in your quote.