Guides / Part XXIV · Disputes, renegotiation, switching and exiting a 3PL
True-up: when an adjustment corrects an estimate
What a true-up must reference, how direction errors and orphan adjustments overcharge you, and a register that pairs every correction with its original.
A true-up is an adjustment on a later invoice that corrects an earlier charge from an estimate to the actual figure. Storage billed on a forecast pallet count gets trued up to the counted pallets. A tier billed on projected volume gets trued up to shipped volume. Done properly, a true-up is how honest billing fixes its own approximations. Done loosely, it is a line nobody can verify, because it points at a past estimate nobody kept.
What a proper true-up looks like
Three elements make a true-up checkable. It names the original: the invoice, period and line it corrects. It shows both figures: what was billed then, what the actual is now, and the difference being charged or credited. And it nets to zero across the pair - original plus true-up should equal the correct charge for the work, no more. A true-up that arrives without a reference, or months after any estimate you can remember, is not a correction mechanism; it is an unexplained charge wearing a correction's name.
Example. March storage was billed provisionally on 180 pallets at $34: $6,120. The count later showed 172 pallets, so the correct charge was 172 × $34 = $5,848, and the April invoice should carry a true-up credit of $272. If April instead carries a true-up charge of $272 labelled "storage adjustment", the pair now totals $6,392 for $5,848 of storage - $544 away from correct, in a line most readers skip because adjustments feel like housekeeping.
How true-ups go wrong
The direction error above is the expensive one: a credit true-up billed as a charge. Next is the orphan true-up, correcting an estimate that was never billed - you pay the correction for an original that does not exist. Then the double true-up: the same original corrected twice, in two different cycles, often under slightly different labels ("period adjustment" is a favourite; ShipMonk's invoices use Period Adjustments as a standard line, which makes referencing discipline matter more, not less - see ShipMonk). Finally, the stale true-up: raised after your dispute window for the original period has closed, so even a wrong one becomes hard to contest.
How to check it
Keep a simple register: every estimated or provisional charge, and every true-up that claims to correct it, paired. Any true-up without a partner in the register gets queried; any estimate that never gets its true-up gets queried too, in the other direction. In a Feeproof audit, a true-up line that cannot be matched to an original is marked Needs evidence, and the pair, once matched, is tested by MATH like any other line. The term is defined in the glossary, alongside the monthly minimum and other adjustment machinery.
Frequently asked questions
What is a true-up on a 3PL invoice?
An adjustment on a later invoice that corrects an earlier charge from an estimate to the actual figure: storage billed on a forecast pallet count gets trued up to the counted pallets, or a tier billed on projected volume gets trued up to shipped volume.
What should a proper true-up show?
Three things: the original it corrects (invoice, period and line), both figures (what was billed then, what the actual is now, and the difference), and a net of zero across the pair, so the original plus the true-up equals the correct charge for the work.
How do true-ups go wrong?
The expensive error is a credit true-up billed as a charge. Others are the orphan true-up, correcting an estimate that was never billed; the double true-up, correcting the same original twice; and the stale true-up, raised after your dispute window for the original period has closed.
How does Feeproof handle a true-up?
A true-up line that cannot be matched to an original is marked Needs evidence. Once the pair is matched, it is tested by MATH like any other line.