Guides / Part XXIV · Disputes, renegotiation, switching and exiting a 3PL
Minimums, peak windows and dispute windows
Three contract terms decide if a disputed 3PL charge comes back: how the minimum is billed, when peak surcharges apply and how long you have to dispute.
Most disputes over 3PL invoices are about prices. The ones brands lose are usually lost on three other terms: how the monthly minimum is billed, when peak surcharges may apply, and how long you have to dispute. Find these three in your contract before you need them.
The monthly minimum
Almost every 3PL has one. What matters is how it is billed:
- Pay-the-difference. The minimum is a floor. If your fees for the month are $420 and the minimum is $750, you pay $750 in total: your $420 plus a $330 top-up. In a month above $750, no minimum line should appear.
- A fee on top. The minimum is charged in full, whatever your other fees. This is rarer and much more expensive in a slow month.
- What counts toward it. Some contracts count only fulfillment fees toward the minimum, some count storage and receiving too. The difference decides whether a top-up was due at all.
On the invoice, check that the top-up equals the minimum minus the fees that count toward it, and that it is missing in months above the minimum.
Peak windows
Peak surcharges are allowed only in the window the contract sets, for example from 1 November to 31 December. Two things go wrong:
- The surcharge starts early or ends late. A peak fee on orders shipped in October, or in January, is outside the window.
- The surcharge never ends. A peak fee that is still on the March invoice is a recurring charge the contract does not allow.
Write the window's dates on your rate card, and check the charge date of every peak line against them.
The dispute window
Many contracts give you a fixed number of days after the invoice date to dispute a charge, often 30 or 60. After that, the invoice counts as accepted. Two consequences:
- Audit every invoice when it arrives, not once a quarter. A quarterly 3PL invoice audit can find errors that are already outside the window.
- Dispute in writing, with the details. Name the invoice, the line, the amount and the reason. Keep the email: its date proves you disputed in time.
Where to find these terms
They are rarely in the price table. Look in the sections on billing, invoicing and payment terms, in the footnotes of the quote, and in the 3PL's terms of service, which many contracts include by reference.
Get them checked
Our free quote to rate card tool lists the minimums, peak windows and exclusions it finds in your contract, each with the text it comes from. A free audit checks your latest invoice against them.
Frequently asked questions
How should a 3PL’s monthly minimum be billed?
Usually as pay-the-difference: with $420 of fees and a $750 minimum you pay $750 in total, your $420 plus a $330 top-up, and no minimum line appears in a month above $750. A minimum charged in full on top of your other fees is rarer and much more expensive in a slow month.
When may a 3PL charge a peak surcharge?
Only in the window the contract sets, for example 1 November to 31 December. A peak fee on orders shipped in October or January is outside the window, and one still on the March invoice is a recurring charge the contract does not allow.
How long do I have to dispute a 3PL invoice?
Many contracts give a fixed number of days after the invoice date, often 30 or 60, and after that the invoice counts as accepted. These terms are rarely in the price table: look in the billing, invoicing and payment-terms sections, the quote’s footnotes and the 3PL’s terms of service.
How do I prove I disputed in time?
Dispute in writing, naming the invoice, the line, the amount and the reason, and keep the email: its date proves you disputed in time.
Can Feeproof find these terms in my contract?
Yes. The free quote to rate card tool lists the minimums, peak windows and exclusions it finds in your contract, each with the text it comes from, and a free audit checks your latest invoice against them.