Guides / Part IV · 3PL pricing and the rate card, line by line
Volume tier: the band that sets your unit price
How volume tiers work, why lagged or split tiers overcharge growing brands, and how to test the billed rate against the band your shipped volume earned.
A volume tier is a band in your rate card that sets unit prices according to how much you ship in a period. Ship more, and the price per pick, per order or per carton falls. The tier is the rate card's volume discount, and it only works if the band applied on the invoice is the band your actual volume earned.
How tiers are structured
Tiers are usually defined on orders shipped per month, sometimes on units picked or on total fulfilment spend. A typical pick schedule might read: $0.90 per pick up to 4,999 orders, $0.80 from 5,000 to 9,999, $0.70 from 10,000. Two details decide the money. The first is the counting basis - orders, units and spend produce three different band placements for the same month. The second is whether the tier applies to the whole month's volume once reached (the usual arrangement) or only to the units above each threshold, like income-tax brackets. Contracts are often silent on the second point, and billing systems pick whichever their default is.
Example. You ship 10,400 orders in a month. Under a whole-month tier, all 10,400 orders take the $0.70 pick rate: $7,280. Under a bracket interpretation, the first 4,999 pay $0.90, the next 5,000 pay $0.80 and only 401 pay $0.70: $4,499.10 + $4,000 + $280.70 = $8,779.80. Same volume, same rate card, $1,499.80 apart - purely from a definition nobody wrote down.
How tier billing goes wrong
The most common error is a lagged tier: the billing system applies the band from last month's volume, or from the forecast in your onboarding paperwork, rather than the month just shipped. Growing brands lose most here, because every growth month is billed at the band of the smaller month before it. The mirror error hits shrinking brands in the other direction and is rarely reported by anyone. A second pattern is split volume: brands shipping from two warehouses, or under two accounts, get tiered per location instead of on combined volume, although the contract tiers the account. A third is the quiet one - the tier table itself is replaced during an annual rate revision, and the bands move even when the headline rates do not.
How to check it
Take one month. Count the volume on the contract's counting basis from your own order export - not from the invoice, which is the document under test. Find the band that count falls into, read the rate, and compare it with the rate on the invoice lines. Then ask which volume figure the 3PL used; if they cannot produce it, the tier was applied on faith. Feeproof runs this as part of R4, testing every rate against the tier your shipped volume reaches, with the count reconciled by SUM against your order export. The general failure pattern is failure mode one in 3PL billing errors: ten ways an invoice goes wrong, and the term sits in the glossary.
Frequently asked questions
What is a volume tier?
A band in your rate card that sets unit prices according to how much you ship in a period: ship more, and the price per pick, per order or per carton falls. It only works if the band applied on the invoice is the band your actual volume earned.
Does a tier apply to the whole month’s volume or only to the units above each threshold?
The usual arrangement is the whole month’s volume once the band is reached, but contracts are often silent and billing systems pick their own default. In the page’s example, 10,400 orders cost $7,280 under a whole-month tier and $8,779.80 under a bracket reading, $1,499.80 apart.
How do tier billing errors happen?
The most common is a lagged tier: the band comes from last month’s volume or the forecast in your onboarding paperwork rather than the month just shipped. Others are volume tiered per warehouse or account instead of on the combined volume, and a tier table replaced during an annual rate revision.
How do I check which tier I should have been billed?
Take one month, count the volume on the contract’s counting basis from your own order export (not from the invoice), find the band that count falls into and compare its rate with the invoice lines. Feeproof runs this as R4, with the count reconciled by SUM against your order export.