Guides / Part IV · 3PL pricing and the rate card, line by line
Pick and pack: how the biggest line is built
Base rate plus additional units: how pick and pack is priced, how the base-rate-per-unit error multiplies a month's bill, and how to rebuild the line.
Pick and pack is the charge for the core act of fulfilment: picking an order's items from storage and packing them for shipment. It is usually the largest warehousing line on the invoice, and it is priced in a structure - a base rate for the order including the first unit, plus a smaller rate for each additional unit - that makes its errors systematic rather than random.
How the price is built
A typical schedule reads: $2.30 per order including the first unit, $0.60 per additional unit. Variations matter. Some 3PLs price per unit with no base, some price per order regardless of units, some bundle pick and pack into a flat fulfilment fee with packaging included (ShipHero's model - see ShipHero). Inserts, gift wrap and fragile handling may sit inside the rate or appear as separate lines. Before any number can be checked, the structure in your rate card has to be stated plainly, because the same invoice total can be right under one structure and wrong under another.
Example. You ship 5,000 orders in a month, averaging 1.8 units per order: 9,000 units in total, of which 5,000 are first units and 4,000 are additional. Correct pick and pack: 5,000 × $2.30 + 4,000 × $0.60 = $11,500 + $2,400 = $13,900. If the billing system instead charges the base rate on every unit - 9,000 × $2.30 = $20,700 - the overcharge is $6,800 in a single month, produced by one wrong setting, invisible unless someone rebuilds the line from the order data.
How pick and pack goes wrong
The example's error - base rate applied per unit - is the classic, but the family is larger. Additional units counted from the order's line items rather than its units, so a quantity of three on one line pays for one extra unit instead of two. Multi-box orders billed as multiple orders. Cancelled or returned-to-stock orders billed as shipped. And channel errors: orders picked under the wrong channel's schedule, which is failure mode four in 3PL billing errors: ten ways an invoice goes wrong. What unites them is that every one is settled by the order export: the invoice's version of what shipped either matches your record of what shipped, or it does not.
How to check it
Take the month's order export. Count orders and units. Rebuild the pick and pack line using the rate card's structure - base times orders, additional rate times units beyond the first per order - and compare the rebuilt figure with the billed one, order count first, then money. Feeproof does this on every invoice: quantities reconciled by SUM against the order export, rates tested by R4 against the contracted structure, and any order billed but absent from the export flagged individually. The term sits in the glossary with the rest of the invoice vocabulary.
Frequently asked questions
How is pick and pack priced?
Typically a base rate for the order including the first unit, plus a smaller rate for each additional unit, for example $2.30 per order and $0.60 per additional unit. Some 3PLs price per unit with no base, some per order regardless of units, and some bundle pick and pack into a flat fulfilment fee.
What is the classic pick-and-pack error?
The base rate applied to every unit. In the page’s example, 5,000 orders with 9,000 units should cost 5,000 × $2.30 + 4,000 × $0.60 = $13,900; charging the base rate on every unit gives $20,700, which is $6,800 over in a single month.
What other pick-and-pack errors occur?
Additional units counted from the order’s line items rather than its units, multi-box orders billed as multiple orders, cancelled or returned-to-stock orders billed as shipped, and orders picked under the wrong channel’s schedule.
How do I check a pick-and-pack line?
Rebuild it from the month’s order export using the rate card’s structure (base times orders, plus the additional rate times units beyond the first per order) and compare order count first, then money. Feeproof reconciles quantities by SUM against the order export, tests rates with R4 and flags any order billed but absent from the export.