Guides / Part XIV · Billing, invoice auditing and cost control
3PL invoice audit FAQ
What a free audit checks, flat fees vs a cut of recovery, why no 3PL passwords or Shopify keys are needed, how credits arrive and what an audit cannot see.
Questions brands ask before they hand a 3PL invoice to an auditor, answered directly: what the free audit covers, why the fee is flat instead of a cut of the recovery, what files you actually have to share, and - just as important - what an audit cannot see. If your question is about what an audit is in the first place, start with what a 3PL invoice audit is.
Cost and billing
What does the free audit check?
Everything a paid audit checks, on one invoice. You upload your latest invoice from any 3PL plus your contract, rate card or quote, and every billed line is run through the same checks: line arithmetic, duplicate charges, fees that are not in the contract, rates above the contract price, peak fees billed out of season, minimum top-ups larger than the shortfall, and the invoice total reconciled against your order export. You get the full report - every amount given a status - and a dispute letter for what the checks prove. No credit card is required.
Why don't you charge a percentage of what you recover?
Because a percentage pays the auditor for finding large numbers, not for being right. A contingency fee rewards aggressive claims, including claims the contract does not support, and it makes your cost unpredictable in exactly the months your bill was most wrong. A flat fee means the audit costs the same whether it finds $40 or $4,000, and every finding has to stand on the contract text and the arithmetic alone. You keep 100% of every credit.
What is the difference between $59 a month and an enterprise platform at $1,000+ a month?
Scope and plumbing. Enterprise platforms are built for operations teams running several warehouses and carrier contracts: they connect to your systems by API or EDI, reconcile freight and parcel as well as warehousing, and charge for that integration and the onboarding around it. Feeproof does one job - checking 3PL invoices against your contract and your order records - and starts from files you already have, so there is nothing to integrate and no setup fee. If you ship from one 3PL and your problem is the monthly bill, the extra $941 buys infrastructure you will not use. The comparison page puts the published offers side by side.
What do the paid plans add over the free audit?
History and repetition. The free audit covers your latest invoice. Starter ($59 a month, up to 3,000 orders) audits invoices back 3 months, Pro ($149, up to 15,000 orders) back 12 months, and Business ($299, up to 50,000 orders) back 24 months - and keeps checking every new invoice as it arrives, so a fee spike or a new recurring surcharge is caught the month it starts rather than a year later. All plans include every check and dispute letter generation. Plans are month-to-month, and subscriptions carry a 14-day full refund policy.
Data and security
Do I have to give you my 3PL portal password or Shopify keys?
No. Feeproof never asks for them. You upload the invoice file (CSV, spreadsheet or PDF), your contract or rate card, and an order export from your store - files you download yourself, from your own accounts, in your own time. There are no API keys, no portal logins and no integrations to revoke later, because none were ever created.
What happens to my files?
They are used to produce your audit report and nothing else. The audit is deterministic code, not a person reading your margins: the same inputs always produce the same findings. Your contract pricing is the evidence base for your disputes, and it is treated as your confidential document - see the security page for how files are stored and handled.
My invoice is a scanned PDF. Does that work?
Yes. Scanned and photographed invoices are read the same way as native PDFs and spreadsheets. Illegible lines are not guessed at: anything the audit cannot read or cannot prove is marked Not tested in the report, with the reason, rather than being silently passed or silently accused.
The process
How long does an audit take?
The checking itself is fast - it is code, not a person with a spreadsheet. What takes time is assembling clean inputs: the invoice, the contract version that was in force for that billing period, and the order export for the same dates. With those three files ready, the report follows without a multi-week onboarding; there is no implementation project to schedule first.
Who sends the dispute letter?
You do. Feeproof writes the letter - each disputed line with the contract clause, the evidence and the corrected arithmetic - but it goes to your 3PL from you, under your name, when you choose to send it. Your 3PL relationship is yours; an auditor appearing out of nowhere with your account details helps nobody's negotiation.
How long until the credit reaches my account?
That depends on your 3PL and your contract, and any auditor who promises a date is guessing. What decides it is the dispute window in your agreement - some 3PLs deem an invoice accepted after 15 or 30 days - and how the 3PL issues credits, usually as a credit memo against a future invoice rather than a refund. What an audit controls is the part that matters most: a dispute filed inside the window, with the evidence attached, so the clock and the paperwork are never the reason a valid claim fails.
Scope
Which 3PLs does it work with?
Any 3PL that issues an itemised invoice. Because the audit starts from files rather than an integration, it is not limited to a list of connected platforms. The dedicated guides cover the billing rules of providers such as ShipBob, ShipMonk, ShipHero, Stord and others, and the same checks apply to a regional 3PL with no guide page - the contract you upload is the rulebook either way.
Can it audit more than one 3PL?
Yes. Invoices and history are kept separate per 3PL, and each 3PL is checked against its own contract - rates, minimums and dispute windows differ, and mixing them would corrupt both audits. Brands that split volume across two warehouses, or that changed provider mid-year, audit each one on its own terms.
How far back can it look?
By plan: 3 months on Starter, 12 on Pro, 24 on Business. One caution before you rely on old invoices: most contracts limit how far back a dispute can reach, whatever the audit finds. Errors older than your dispute window are still worth knowing - they tell you what to watch on current bills - but the recoverable money is usually in the recent months, which is where an audit starts.
Limits
What can an audit not find?
Anything that leaves no trace in the three sources. If a charge depends on a fact that is not in the invoice, the contract or your records - the true dimensions of a carton nobody measured, a pallet count from a receiving dock with no paperwork - the line is marked Not tested or Needs evidence rather than given a verdict. Feeproof does not do inventory reconciliation, does not count your stock, and does not renegotiate carrier rates; it checks the bill you were sent against the deal you signed and the orders you shipped. The ten failure modes it does catch are listed in 3PL billing errors: ten ways an invoice goes wrong.