Guides
3PL invoice audit: 15 checks and how to run one
A 3PL invoice audit checks every billed line against your contract and your order records. See the 15 checks, then audit your latest invoice free.
A 3PL invoice audit checks every line of a third-party logistics invoice against the prices in your contract, rate card or quote and your own records of what happened: the orders you shipped, the stock you received, the space you used. Every billed amount is proved right, proved wrong or marked as needing evidence.
Anything proved wrong becomes a dispute with your 3PL, backed by the contract text and the arithmetic. This guide covers the invoice your 3PL sends you, not a warehouse operations audit, a carrier audit or an audit of a 3PL's own accounts.
This page is the map of the subject. It sets out what an audit compares, the fifteen checks Feeproof runs, what a billed line can turn out to be, where invoices usually go wrong and how long you have to dispute, and it points to the guide on each part.
Why 3PL invoices need auditing at all
A 3PL invoice is not one price. It is hundreds or thousands of small charges - receiving, storage, picks, packaging, labels, returns, account fees - each billed on its own unit, tier and rule. The total can look reasonable while individual lines are wrong: a pick billed at the wrong tier, a delivery received once and billed twice, a fee that was never in the contract, a surcharge that only applies in peak weeks billed in March.
The causes are ordinary. A billing system keys the volume tier to last month's count. A rate card is replaced but the old version stays loaded. A per-unit fee is multiplied by orders, or an order is coded to the wrong sales channel. 3PL billing errors: ten ways an invoice goes wrong walks through each with the arithmetic.
Spot-checking does not catch this. The errors are small, they repeat every month, and each one is buried in an export nobody has time to recompute by hand. An audit exists to check all of it, every month, the same way.
What an audit compares
Every charge on the invoice should be provable from three sources:
- The invoice itself. Lines should add up, quantities should match their rates, and nothing should appear twice.
- The contract, rate card or quote. Each price, tier, free allowance, minimum and exclusion you agreed. This is the document that decides what a charge was allowed to be. If you only have a quote, turning it into a rate card is the first step.
- Your own records. Your order export shows what shipped. Your receiving and inventory records show what arrived and what space it took. A charge for an order that never shipped fails against this source even if the rate is right.
An audit that uses only the invoice finds arithmetic errors. An audit that also uses the contract finds wrong rates and invented fees. An audit that uses all three finds charges for things that never happened.
3PL invoice audit vs parcel audit vs freight audit
| Audit | Whose bill | What it checks |
|---|---|---|
| 3PL invoice audit | The invoice your 3PL sends you | Receiving, storage, picks, packaging, returns, account fees and postage, against your contract and your order records |
| Parcel audit | Your parcel carrier's invoice | Billed rates, surcharges and late-delivery refunds, against the carrier's contract and service guarantees |
| Freight audit | Your freight carrier's invoice | Billed rate, accessorials and weight on pallet and truckload shipments, against the freight contract |
When your 3PL ships on its own carrier accounts, the carrier's invoice goes to the 3PL, not to you. The postage on your invoice and the carrier surcharges your 3PL passes through (accessorial fees) are then checked like any other fee: against the rates in your contract, and per package against their own history.
The 15 checks of a 3PL invoice audit
A complete audit runs the same fifteen checks on every invoice, a checklist that falls into three groups by what each one needs.
From the invoice and the invoices before it
| Check | What it flags |
|---|---|
| Line arithmetic | A line that bills more than its own quantity times its own rate. |
| Duplicate charges | The same charge billed twice: the same order, shipment or SKU, a monthly fee billed again in its month, or a line repeated from an earlier invoice. |
| New fees | A fee type that appears for the first time. Against a contract it is a charge the agreement does not allow; without one it is a question for your 3PL. |
| Fee spikes | A fee 50% or more above its average over the previous three invoices that carried it, and at least 25 more in the invoice currency. Needs two earlier invoices with the fee. A spike is a question to ask, not a claim, because volume can grow for good reasons. |
| Cost per order | The whole invoice per order billed, 15% or more above its average over the previous three invoices. Needs two earlier invoices. |
| Postage per package | Postage per package 15% or more above its average over the previous three invoices. Needs two earlier invoices. The invoice does not show what the carrier charged, so a markup cannot be measured, but where the contract caps the markup the check asks for the carrier's costs. |
Against the contract
| Check | What it flags |
|---|---|
| Rates above contract | A unit price higher than the rate card says, tier by tier, zone by zone and weight band by weight band. A line within 0.01 of the contract amount passes. |
| Recurring surcharges | A fee the contract does not list that comes back at a steady amount, within 10%, three months in a row. |
| Free allowances | Free units each month that were not taken off before billing. |
| Peak fees out of season | A peak or holiday surcharge billed outside the window the contract allows. |
| Minimum top-ups | A top-up that bills more than the shortfall between the minimum and the month's charges that count toward it. |
| Card fees | A card processing fee billed to a brand that pays by bank transfer or check. |
| Promised credits | A credit the 3PL promised that is missing from the first invoice after the promise. |
Against your own records
| Check | What it flags |
|---|---|
| Orders the export does not record | An order the 3PL billed that your order export does not show. Each fee of that order is disputed in full. |
| Totals against your orders | For a fee priced per order, unit, return or receipt, the billed total against the contract rate times the count in your records. This is how an invoice that shows only totals gets checked. |
Each finding needs its evidence attached: the contract sentence with the agreed price, the record that shows what happened, and the arithmetic that produces the correct amount. A dispute without those three things is an opinion, and 3PLs refund proof, not opinions.
A finding, end to end
Your contract prices picks at $0.85 for 5,000 to 9,999 orders a month and $0.70 from 10,000. Your order export shows 11,240 orders shipped in the month, but the invoice bills the picks at $0.85. The contract sentence, the order count and the sum are the three pieces of evidence: 11,240 × $0.85 = $9,554 billed against 11,240 × $0.70 = $7,868 allowed, a difference of $1,686 from one line. The $7,868 is supported; the $1,686 above it is the disputed amount, and it goes into a letter with all three pieces attached. The same case is the first of the ten on the page linked above.
A monthly minimum works the same way. Your contract sets a minimum of $1,000 a month, and the month's charges that count toward it come to $880, so the most the 3PL can add is the $120 shortfall. The invoice bills a $200 top-up: $120 is supported and the $80 above it is disputed. The figures in both cases are illustrative.
What a billed line can turn out to be
Every billed amount ends in exactly one of five states, and the states add up to the invoice total:
| Status | What it means |
|---|---|
| Supported | The amount matches the contract price and quantity, or your records prove it. |
| Calculation mismatch | The arithmetic does not give the billed amount: quantity times the contract rate is lower, or the same charge appears twice. The part above is the disputed difference. |
| Conflicts with terms | The charge contradicts a term of the contract, such as a fee it excludes, a peak fee outside the peak window, a card fee on a brand that pays by transfer or a promised credit that never came. |
| Needs evidence | The files neither prove the amount right nor wrong, and the report says what would settle it. |
| Not tested | A check lacked what it needs, such as a confirmed contract price or an order export. The amount is neither passed nor accused. |
Nothing is waved through because nobody looked, and nothing is accused without its working shown. For the amounts proved wrong, you get a dispute letter ready to send, the deadline it has to be sent by, and a record of every credit your 3PL promises, so a promised credit that never appears gets noticed.
How Feeproof does it
An AI reader recognises the layout of your invoice file and reads your contract into a rate card, quoting the contract sentence behind every price. You confirm each contract fact before it is used. From then on code does every sum: what the contract allows, each difference and the letter total. The AI computes no amount. Given the same files and the same confirmed contract, the checks give the same result every time, and the report shows each amount with its formula and the invoice lines it comes from, so you can redo any sum in a spreadsheet. How we handle your files has the details, and About Feeproof says who makes it.
Where invoices go wrong
Errors visible on the invoice alone
Some errors need no contract. Seven 3PL billing errors visible on the invoice covers duplicate lines, lines that do not add up, rates that drift, new fees, surcharges that stay, spikes and totals that do not match, and what proof to send your 3PL for each.
Rates, tiers and units
The biggest lines are priced in structures that make errors systematic. Pick and pack is usually the largest warehousing line, built from a base rate for the order including its first unit plus a smaller rate for each additional unit. The volume tier sets those rates by how much you ship, and a tier billed one band too high repeats every month. Storage basis decides whether you pay per pallet, per bin or per cubic foot, and the same stock produces different bills under each. The structure in your rate card has to be stated plainly before any number can be checked.
Fees on top of the rates
Accessorial fees are every charge beyond the base pick, pack and storage rates: the carrier surcharges your 3PL passes through and the warehouse's own extras. Each one is triggered by a condition - a size, a weight, a ZIP code, a date - and a fee billed without its trigger is disputable. DIM weight is the sharpest example. A carrier bills the greater of the scale weight and a weight calculated from the box's size, so one wrong dimension on file repeats on every shipment of a product. The DIM weight calculator shows what a box should bill as.
Terms that decide the bill
Brands usually lose disputes on three terms: how the monthly minimum is billed, when peak surcharges may apply and how long you have to dispute. Minimums, peak windows and dispute windows shows where to find each in your contract. A true-up is an adjustment that corrects an earlier estimate to the actual figure; a proper one names the original charge, shows both figures and nets to zero. The 3PL billing glossary defines the terms used on this page and on invoice lines.
From finding to credit
A finding becomes money only through a dispute. How to dispute 3PL charges takes it in five steps: find your dispute window first, because most contracts allow a fixed number of days from the invoice date and the charge stands after it; dispute only what you can prove; attach the contract text, your record and the arithmetic to each line; send one letter that lists every charge; and track the credit until it lands. The finish line is a credit memo. Until one exists, you do not have a credit, you have a conversation.
How long you have to dispute 3PL charges
Most contracts allow a fixed number of days from the invoice date, and the charge stands after it. Of the 18 3PLs covered here, six publish a clock for invoice errors and twelve publish none, so for most the window is the one in your contract. As of November 2026:
| 3PL | Clock |
|---|---|
| Simpl Fulfillment | Written notice within 30 days of the invoice being issued (Section 5C); after that the dispute is waived. |
| Bigblue (UK) | Written dispute, with the reason, within six weeks of the invoice being issued (clause 5.8); after that the invoice is deemed accepted. |
| Stord | Written dispute with supporting evidence before the payment falls due (Section 4.7); after that the dispute is waived. |
| ShipBob | Can correct operational errors within 90 days of the transaction date; an inventory discrepancy must reach ShipBob within 48 hours of delivery. |
| Flexport (Deliverr) | Refunds for fees charged on wrong dimensions cover only orders from the last 30 days; order claims close 30 days after the promised delivery date. |
| Huboo | Query an invoice promptly, on presentation (clause 5.10); Huboo aims to answer within 3 business days. |
All 18 clocks are in what 18 3PLs publish about their prices; minimums, peak windows and dispute windows shows where to find the one in your contract.
What your 3PL publishes about its prices
An audit needs something to check against. For some 3PLs that is a public price list; for most it is not. What 18 3PLs publish about their prices records, as of November 2026, which publish a price list, which publish only the billing rules and which publish no prices at all. Each of the 18 has its own page with a breakdown of its billing: ShipBob, ShipMonk, ShipHero, Radial, Stord, DCL Logistics, Red Stag Fulfillment, Flexport (Deliverr), Fulfillment.com, Ryder E-commerce, Quiet Logistics, Fulfyld, Simpl Fulfillment, J&J Global Fulfilment, Bigblue (UK), Hive, byrd and Huboo. The same checks apply to a 3PL with no page here: the contract you upload is the rulebook either way, and it wins over anything published.
By hand, by spreadsheet, or by service
You can audit by hand, and for a handful of orders a month you should: the quick check finds duplicates, new fees, lines that do not add up and fee spikes from the invoice alone, free, and the audit checklist lists the twenty steps for the rest. The cost of doing it by hand grows with order volume, because every line has to be matched against the contract and your records one at a time.
Audit services and software differ mostly in what they charge and what they need from you. Some charge a share of the credits they recover, typically 25% to 50% for parcel refunds according to Fulfill.com's parcel audit guide (September 2026), or set the fee in a private agreement, which cannot be compared from a web page. Some need integrations with your store and your 3PL's systems before they can start. Feeproof charges a flat monthly price by order volume - from $59 a month - works from the files you already have, and audits your latest invoice free, so the first audit shows what your invoices contain before you pay anything. 3PL invoice audit services compared sets seven services side by side from what each publishes about itself, and there are separate comparisons with Implentio, WareAudit, SpendVerify and billsharp.
What you need to start
Three files: the invoice as an itemised CSV or PDF, the contract version that was in force for that billing period, and the order export for the same dates. A scanned PDF works, and a line that cannot be read is marked not tested instead of guessed at. The audit starts from files, not from an integration, so it is not limited to a list of connected platforms, and we never ask for passwords, API keys or access to your 3PL portal or your store. With those three files the report follows without an onboarding project.
How often, and how far back
Errors repeat every month, so an audit is worth running on every invoice, not once. How far back it can look depends on the plan: three months on Starter, 12 on Pro and 24 on Business. Most contracts limit how far back a dispute can reach whatever the audit finds, so the recoverable money is usually in the recent months, which is where an audit starts.
What an audit cannot do
An audit finds what leaves a trace in the invoice, the contract or your records. A charge that depends on a fact in none of them - the true dimensions of a carton nobody measured, a pallet count from a dock with no paperwork - is marked not tested or needs evidence, not given a verdict. Feeproof does not count your stock, does not reconcile inventory and does not renegotiate carrier rates. And a finding is not a refund: what you recover is the part you can prove, inside your dispute window, that your 3PL credits. The FAQ covers these limits and more.
Free tools to start with
- Invoice quick check: duplicates, new fees, lines that do not add up and fee spikes from an invoice export.
- Quote to rate card: every price in a quote or contract as a row with its source text.
- DIM weight calculator: what a box should bill as under each carrier's divisor.
- 3PL invoice audit checklist: the twenty steps to audit an invoice yourself.
- 3PL cost per order calculator: each bucket of an invoice or a quote divided by the orders shipped.
- 3PL overcharge estimator: what a share of billing errors is worth on your spend.
Start with the invoice you already have
The fastest first audit needs no setup: run the invoice quick check on your latest export, or turn your quote into a rate card you can check against. If you want the full check against your contract, the first audit is free. To see what the result looks like first, what a Feeproof audit finds shows a sample report.
Frequently asked questions
What is a 3PL invoice audit?
A line-by-line check of a third-party logistics invoice against the prices you agreed in your contract, rate card or quote, and against your own records of what happened: the orders you shipped, the stock you received, the space you used. Every billed amount is proved right, proved wrong, or marked as needing evidence.
What does an audit compare an invoice with?
Three sources: the invoice itself (lines add up, nothing appears twice), the contract or quote (each price, tier, allowance, minimum and exclusion) and your own records (order export, receiving and inventory). The invoice alone finds arithmetic errors; with the contract it finds wrong rates and invented fees; with all three it finds charges for things that never happened.
How is a 3PL invoice audit different from a parcel audit?
A parcel audit checks the carrier’s invoice against the carrier’s terms, for example late-delivery refunds. A 3PL invoice audit checks the invoice your 3PL sends you against your contract and your order records. When the 3PL ships on its own carrier accounts you never see the carrier’s invoice, so its postage line is checked against your contract.
What are the most common 3PL billing errors?
Duplicate charges, rates above contract, lines whose quantity times rate does not equal the amount billed, fees the contract never mentions, recurring surcharges, peak fees out of season, minimum top-ups larger than the shortfall, totals that disagree with your orders, and fee spikes.
How much money can a brand recover from an audit?
No independent study measures it, so any average you read is a vendor’s own claim: Implentio’s savings calculator assumes 3% of logistics spend, billsharp’s estimator 14%. The reliable figure is the one measured on your own invoices. Feeproof’s free audit gives every billed dollar on your latest invoice a status, and the dispute letter lists only the amounts the checks prove.
Does Feeproof take a percentage of what I recover?
No. Feeproof charges a flat monthly fee by the orders you ship, the first audit is free, and you keep everything you recover. Services paid on contingency, common for parcel refunds, keep 25% to 50% of what they recover (Fulfill.com, September 2026).
How often should I audit my 3PL invoice?
Every invoice. Errors repeat each month, so a tier or rate billed wrongly stays wrong until someone catches it, and most contracts limit how far back a dispute can reach, so the recoverable money is in the recent invoices. One audit finds one month’s errors; an audit each month stops them repeating.
How long do I have to dispute a 3PL charge?
The contract decides. Many allow a fixed number of days from the invoice date, and the charge stands after it. Simpl Fulfillment publishes 30 days and Bigblue six weeks; most of the 18 3PLs we reviewed publish no window at all, so find the one in your contract before you send anything.
Can I audit a 3PL invoice myself?
Yes. For a handful of orders a month, the invoice quick check and the 20-step audit checklist are enough. The work grows with order volume, because every line has to be matched against the contract and your order records one at a time.